Retirement should be a time of freedom—from deadlines and piles of to-dos. But you likely won’t be free of taxes. Although you won’t incur payroll taxes if you’ve stopped working, you will likely continue to owe other taxes on some of the withdrawals you take from retirement accounts, and on other retirement benefits. On the positive side, you may be in a lower tax bracket in retirement because you won’t be receiving a full-time salary anymore. However, you still may owe taxes on capital gains, withdrawals from retirement accounts, pension payments, Social Security benefits, and possibly a part-time job.
One important element of tax-sensitive investing is developing a withdrawal strategy. A withdrawal strategy aims to help provide you with the income you need, minimize the effects of taxes, and keep your investment mix diversified and in line with your personal situation.
"Most investors are familiar with the idea of trying to maximize their assets by minimizing taxes during their earning and wealth-building years," says Ken Hevert, senior vice president of retirement products at Fidelity. “Limiting taxes on those savings in retirement is equally important.”
Here are four different tax-efficient withdrawal strategies to consider.
|Strategy #1:||Consider the basic retirement withdrawal sequence.|
The simplest withdrawal strategy is to take assets from your retirement and savings accounts in the following order:
- Minimum required distributions (MRDs), sometimes referred to as required minimum distributions (RMDs), from retirement accounts1
- Taxable accounts
- Tax-deferred retirement accounts, such as a traditional IRA, 401(k), 403(b), or 457
- Tax-exempt retirement accounts, such as a Roth IRA or Roth 401(k)
This approach offers several advantages. First, it ensures that you take any MRDs, which are required for traditional and Roth 401(k) plans and traditional IRAs if you’re older than 70½.2 (Roth IRAs don’t have MRDs while the original owner is alive.) If you don’t take the full MRD, in most cases you’ll pay a penalty worth half the amount you failed to withdraw.
After you’ve taken your MRD (or if you’re not yet 70½), you can take retirement income from taxable accounts until you’ve exhausted them. You’ll likely have to sell investments, in which case you’ll pay capital gains tax on any appreciation.
If you’ve held the investment for longer than a year, you’ll generally be taxed at long-term capital gains rates, which currently range from 0% to 20%, depending on your tax bracket (a 3.8% Medicare tax may also apply for high-income earners). Generally, for most taxpayers, long-term capital gains are taxed at rates no higher than 15%. Long-term capital gains rates are significantly lower than ordinary income tax rates, which in 2016 ranged from 10.0% to 39.6%, for withdrawals from traditional retirement accounts.
What’s more, using your taxable assets for retirement withdrawals leaves your money in tax-advantaged accounts, where it has the potential to grow tax-deferred. “Compounding earnings on a tax-deferred basis is a powerful way to help grow assets over time,” says Hevert.
If you’ve used up your assets in taxable accounts, turn to your traditional, tax-deferred accounts. You’ll pay ordinary income tax on withdrawals, but this allows you to continue to leave any Roth accounts untouched, which may have significant benefits. Qualified withdrawals from Roth accounts won’t be taxed, making them a useful vehicle later in retirement. For example, if you have a significant medical bill, you can withdraw money from the Roth account to pay for it without triggering a tax liability.3 Moreover, Roth accounts can be effective estate-planning vehicles, because any heirs who inherit them generally won’t owe federal income taxes on their distributions.
The basic withdrawal strategy does have a potential disadvantage, however. Your tax burden may increase when you start taking money from tax-deferred retirement accounts. If that tax bump is a source of concern, consider the following strategy.
|Strategy #2:||Avoid having withdrawals bump you into a higher tax bracket.|
If you want to be a little more active in your withdrawal strategy, you may consider taking simultaneous withdrawals from taxable, tax-deferred, and possibly tax exempt accounts. The objective here is to monitor the source of your withdrawals so that you can understand the effect of the withdrawals on your tax rate and avoid a move into a higher tax bracket.
If you decide to manage your taxable income with a target marginal tax rate (the rate on the last dollar of income earned) in mind, consider following these steps:
Step 1: Identify your expected gross income, living expenses, and income gap (the difference between gross income and expenses) for the coming tax year, before considering any withdrawals from your investment accounts. Then determine your expected level of deductions and exemptions, and subtract them from your gross income, arriving at an estimate of your taxable income before withdrawals from investment accounts.
Step 2: Choose a marginal tax rate you’d like to target in the coming tax year. A reasonable place to start is the marginal rate associated with the taxable income estimate you identified in Step 1. For example, if you expect $48,000 in taxable income before tapping your investment accounts, you could target a marginal rate of 15%, because $48,000 of taxable income is subject to a marginal rate of 15% for joint filers in 2016.
Step 3: Identify and withdraw the amount of additional taxable income (above the level determined in Step 1) that you can recognize without affecting your target marginal tax rate. Assuming you need at least this amount in addition to your noninvestment income to cover your expenses, withdraw it from a tax-deferred account. For example, if you’re married and file jointly, taxable income up to $75,300 is taxed at 15%. So if you expect $22,000 in taxable income from noninvestment sources, you could afford to generate an additional $53,300 through withdrawals from tax-deferred accounts without pushing yourself into the next tax bracket.
Step 4: Now withdraw the additional amount needed to fund your expenses, and cover your tax liability, from a taxable or Roth account. If using a taxable account, try to avoid liquidating securities at a gain, because this can generate additional tax liability; if using a Roth account, make sure that you’ve met the requirements for qualified distributions, or you may face both additional taxes and penalties.
“This strategy may help you generate the cash flow you need to help meet expenses, while potentially minimizing your tax rate," says Matthew Kenigsberg, vice president of Fidelity’s Strategic Advisers. “If performed consistently over time, it may help you preserve more of your retirement assets for the future.”
Meet the Smiths
Consider the following hypothetical scenario4 for Mary and Sammy Smith, a retired married couple whose annual expenses total $100,000. The Smiths expect $42,000 in gross income (all taxable) before tapping their retirement accounts. They anticipate $20,000 in deductions and exemptions, so their expected taxable income before withdrawals is $22,000.
If they withdraw $53,300 from their traditional IRAs, it would bring their taxable income to $75,300—just within the 15% bracket for 2016. They could then withdraw the remaining $4,700 that they need to cover their expenses—their income gap—plus the $10,368 they need to pay taxes due on their $75,300 in taxable income, for a total of $15,068, from a Roth IRA, which does not generate taxable income as long as the withdrawal is qualified.
In order to generate the same $15,068 with additional withdrawals from the traditional IRA, they would have to withdraw $20,091, of which $5,023 would cover taxes on the withdrawal, leaving the $15,068 that they need. So by withdrawing from the Roth instead of the traditional IRA, the Smiths save $5,023 in income taxes for the current year.
Under that scenario, the $20,091 will eventually have to be withdrawn from the traditional IRA, and taxes will have to be paid on it at that time, but as long as taxable income is kept below the top of the 15% bracket, the taxes paid on that withdrawal could be just $3,014 (i.e., $20,091 times 15%), implying a final tax savings of $2,009 (i.e., $5,023 minus $3,014). The chart below shows their cash flow and taxable income under both scenarios:
In the tax-smart withdrawal strategy illustrated above, the Smiths leave the bulk of their Roth IRA assets in place, to potentially generate tax-free growth. In certain situations, however, it may be advantageous to tap Roth assets instead of tax-deferred or taxable accounts. These include situations when:
- Any distributions at all from a tax-deferred account would result in undesirable outcomes not directly related to income tax but that are tied to taxable income, such as increases in Medicare costs.
- Withdrawing from a taxable account would require selling assets held less than a year, resulting in short-term capital gains, which are taxed at ordinary income tax rates.
- You are also trying to minimize taxes on Social Security benefits, as in Strategy #3 (see below), and withdrawals from a tax-deferred account would have an impact on the taxability of those benefits.
Your circumstances may be considerably different from those described in the Smith scenario. Nevertheless, you may be able to apply the principles to your own situation. A tax professional can help you explore the implications of different withdrawal strategies, help minimize the amount of taxes you pay on hard-earned savings, and, of course, help you maximize your ability to live the retirement you envision.
|Strategy #3:||Limit taxation on Social Security benefits.|
This strategy again involves actively managing your distribution strategy. The government considers up to 85% of your Social Security benefits to be taxable, depending on a formula that takes into account most other income sources, plus one-half of your benefits. The objective of this approach is to manage your income so that a smaller percentage of your Social Security benefits will be taxable.
Follow the same approach as outlined in Strategy #2, with one exception: You’ll target the income thresholds that determine whether your Social Security benefits are taxable, rather than income levels associated with a particular tax bracket.
|Strategy #4:||Exploit lower capital gains rates.|
You also may have the opportunity to eliminate taxes on the capital gains you realize from taxable accounts. In 2016, taxpayers in the 10% and 15% income brackets can realize long-term capital gains (or receive qualified dividends) without being taxed. (In 2016, the 15% bracket tops out at taxable income of $75,300 for married couples filing jointly.) The result: If your taxable income falls into one of the two lowest tax brackets, selling stocks held longer than a year could be a highly tax-efficient way to generate cash flow. This strategy is potentially most feasible if you have a relatively high proportion of retirement assets in taxable accounts and a lower amount of recurring annual income, such as Social Security, a pension, or annuity income.
Tax tips for high-income individuals
It is becoming increasingly important for high-income individuals to manage taxable income with a target tax rate in mind. Joint filers earning more than $250,000 per year in modified adjusted gross income (MAGI) and single filers earning more than $200,000 in MAGI per year now face a 3.8% Medicare tax on their income in excess of the MAGI limits or their net investment income (capital gains, interest, dividends, etc.), whichever is less.
Taxpayers may be able to significantly reduce their tax burden by carefully managing their annual income so it remains below these levels. For example, if a couple is below the $250,000 level in a given year but expects to exceed it the following year, they may want to consider accelerating the recognition of taxable income into the current year up to the $250,000 limit. In addition, tax-exempt municipal income is not subject to the 3.8% surtax, so investors who are over the limits may wish to consider replacing taxable bonds and bond funds in their taxable accounts with municipal proxies in order to reduce their exposure to the surtax. Of course, taxes aren’t the only consideration—be sure to look at the risks as well before making a decision. Read Viewpoints: "The Medicare taxes and you."
Fidelity Brokerage Services LLC, Member NYSE, SIPC, 900 Salem Street, Smithfield, RI 02917