10 ways to stop financial elder fraud
See how a son got his dad back on track financially after falling prey to a scam.
- Fidelity Viewpoints
- – 01/31/2023
- Realize that your loved one is a potential target.
- Remember there is fear and shame when scammed, so be empathetic.
- Involve trusted family members in money management jobs.
- Engage multiple family members, to reduce the potential for a single point of failure.
- Keep up to date on local and COVID-related scams.
Mike Conner,* age 57, a chief marketing officer for a health care technology firm in Chicago, offered to help his 86-year-old father with taxes. While visiting his father in Dallas, Conner had noticed that his father, a retired aerospace engineer, had letters on his desk from the Internal Revenue Service related to an unfiled tax return.
His father had an explanation. He was a widower who had remarried a year earlier, and the couple was splitting their time between his home in Dallas and her home outside Phoenix. "He was thrown by how to handle their new marital status and different state residencies, so he had simply done nothing," says Conner.
Conner figured he would ask his own accountant to lend a hand, and that it would be a fairly straightforward task. It hasn't been. As Conner and his father sorted through online documents (bank accounts, brokerage accounts, and credit card statements) to get the information needed to file Conner’s father’s past taxes, Conner made a startling discovery. "Over the course of the previous 18 months, my father got suckered into signing up for 94 financial and investment newsletters from advisory services, totaling $56,000 in ‘subscription fees,’ which he paid for with his credit cards," says Conner. "His retirement portfolio is worth around $500,000."
By all accounts, it’s a case of elder financial abuse. Although not outright theft, 51 of the newsletters that could be traced came from one financial firm and its 7 sister companies. "I don’t think they broke laws," says Conner. "If you met my dad today, you would say, boy, I hope I’m as sharp and on top of things as he is at that age, but, in fact, he has lost executive processing skills."
Conner's father's financial chaos is one increasingly shared by adult children across the country, especially during the COVID pandemic. Helping older family members manage their money can be awkward, but it's often inevitable.
"Financial elder fraud is a sophisticated on line endeavor and it can happen to anyone. Normalizing awareness is key to helping you avoid it or navigating a crisis event as a family." says Dr. Tim Habbershon, Managing Director of Family Engagement at Fidelity. "There is often defensiveness or anger when the subject is raised because of the fear and shame that can be associated with diminished capacity. Children need to have empathy and not get caught in the emotional reactivity of the situation."
Conner didn't want to embarrass his dad but asked him point-blank, "Are you acting on any of this advice? Dad, you are not going to begin trading options at age 85."
In retrospect, Conner grasps what happened. Part of it was his father's romantic desire to show off to his new wife with vacations and dinners out. He was worried that he needed more income to do so and believed investing would bump up his bank account.
It was also his dad's personality. "He is one of these very meticulous people who measures a dozen times before he cuts once," says Conner. "When I was growing up, he always bought a lot of tools for house projects, but he had way more tools than accomplished projects. I think that's why he became susceptible to all the financial tools salespeople who came down the pike."
While each of us will face a different scenario—and it might not be a parent but rather an aunt or uncle whose financial safety is at stake—there are 10 steps to take now before a crisis develops:
1. Begin a family conversation
"It doesn't have to be all about aging issues," says Elizabeth Loewy, the former founding chief of the Elder Abuse Unit in the New York County District Attorney's Office, and general counsel and senior vice president for industry relations at EverSafe, an online account monitoring service. "It is really about just talking. Start with your own situation. You might say, 'I want an extra set of eyes on my financial accounts. Would you mind getting alerts if something happens? I can do the same for you.' You make it a 2-way street."
One way to navigate these conversations is to use the Transparency<—>Disclosure continuum, suggests Habbershon. We often make financial conversations an all-or-nothing topic—"I need to know everything" or "You want to know everything." Instead, on a continuum you ask, "How much transparency feels good to you?" and "What would you rather keep for future disclosures?" This type of conversation allows for comfort and growth—you can expand the transparency through time.
2. Create a family financial management plan
First, remember that money is an intimate space. "Trying to act as if a financial plan is just a rational thing to do will get the opposite emotional response," says Habbershon. Second, acknowledge the realities out loud: This is new, this feels hard, we are at a different life stage, let's partner for the future. And third, start slowly and don't overwhelm. For example, in case of emergency, who are your parents' financial professionals and trusted advisors? Who is the lawyer, accountant, financial planner, and broker? Do you have contact information for a neighbor or someone who sees your parents regularly if you have concerns? Can you share access to online accounts, so you can more openly discuss money management?
3. Know what key documents have been completed
Getting organized begins with knowing what has and hasn't been done. According to Habbershon, since diminishing capacity is an aging reality that starts somewhere in mid-adulthood, we can plan for late-in-life decline. For instance, a financial (durable) power of attorney (POA) should be granted to someone who is comfortable dealing with investing and other money matters. Conner's father, for instance, gave POAs to both Conner and his sister.
And ask questions. But, Habbershon reminds us, ask permission or ask to be invited in: "Would it be alright if...?" or "How would you feel about...?" Then: "Do you have a will? When did you create it? Is it still current?" Do an inventory on insurance policies. Ask whether your parents have designated beneficiaries on bank accounts, investment accounts, and insurance policies. Do they have a health care proxy? Living will? Where are all these documents stored?
Tip: Here's a list of the important documents you will need: a will, a living will, separate durable POAs for health care and financial decision making, deeds, insurance policies, investment accounts, bank accounts, income statements, retirement accounts, all outstanding loan documents, and current bills.
4. Be alert to changes in financial accounts
There is no flashing red light when someone starts to lose financial capability. "The heart of the matter is we should build the late-in-life relationships that allow us to be engaged around life and financial activities," counsels Habbershon.
For 2 years, Conner was aware that his father subscribed to a few investor newsletters, before Conner discovered the magnitude of the charges. It had started after his parents' financial advisor of more than 2 decades retired. "Dad didn't have much rapport with the younger associate now handling his account. Then a friend came along bragging about this great thing he was doing in his portfolio, and dad decided he could do better," recalls Conner.
"He began talking with me about how he was thinking of buying individual stocks, so there were the beginnings of lines of communication between my dad and me. I should have asked more probing questions, but I was very busy with life and work. I was also running up against how far you push with a parent. I didn't say 'show me what you are doing' or 'knock it off.'"
Then, too, Conner and his 2 siblings always thought it was their father who was responsible for financial management in their family. After all, he paid the bills. But, in retrospect, they realize that it was their mother, who died 5 years ago, who played a very big governing role and had been his sounding board. "She would be the one to say 'No, we don't need to do that,'" says Conner.
Tip: Watch for warning signs: not knowing what bills have been paid, obvious spending habit fluctuation, bounced checks, and late payment charges on credit cards.
5. Simplify finances
Two months after Conner discovered his father's charges, his new wife moved to Conner's father's home. The siblings used the move as a new beginning for their dad.
They cleaned house financially. He had 6 credit cards, and Conner's sister whittled those down to 1 debit card connected to his credit union and 2 credit cards. She also reviewed expenses, put her father on a budget, and set up automatic bill paying and direct deposit into a checking account for any income. Conner's stepmother's daughter had already taken over financial management of her mother's affairs, paying the bills and giving her mother an allowance.
6. Keep up to date on local scams
Educate your parents about the scam du jour. A good tactical way to start a conversation is to just ask, "Have you heard about the latest scam?"
Remind them regularly to never reply to any request by email, regular mail, or phone for personal information such as a Social Security or credit card number, or to pitches to purchase a product or investment that they didn't request.
It's not always an outright scam, as in the case of Conner's father's newsletters. But it's over and above what someone in their mid-80s needs or would consume—things like a multiyear ticket subscription to a symphony orchestra concert series or 3 pairs of $350 silk pants are just not needed or prudent. Habbershon suggests making identifying scams a "family sport"—having everyone watching for scams, sending email chains, discussing scams, and creating a family connection around it.
The website for the Federal Trade Commission has helpful information on identifying, reporting, and avoiding a variety of scams.
Tip: If you or someone you know has been a victim of exploitation, consider making a report to the Department of Justice National Elder Abuse Hotline or to the FBI Internet Complaint Center.
7. Maintain a social connection
Isolation is a trigger for financial problems. And, Habbershon acknowledges, connection can be hard because of geography, life-pace, or family dynamics. Often our own guilt about not being connected leads us to do nothing. "We need to be more compassionate to ourselves—this is just life—so just doing what you can is a good thing." Even something as simple as starting family email or text chains, or calling just to talk instead of to address an issue, can nurture relationships. Any engagement is better than no engagement, so if you get a "ping" about reaching out, just do whatever you can offer. And if you're not sure what to say or where to begin, simply asking caring questions and listening is a great place to start.
8. Assign money management jobs
Money management can be handled in a divide-and-conquer strategy. In Conner's family, for example, because his sister lives near their father, she has taken on the duties of monitoring credit card accounts, bill paying, and checking credit reports regularly. His stepmother's daughter checks the couples' bank accounts and debit card use daily.
An additional option is to designate a family member as a “trusted contact” for a parent or loved one: that is, a person whom a financial institution may contact in certain circumstances, such as concern about activity in the elder person’s account and the elder person cannot be reached. Naming a trusted contact doesn’t give that person authority to act on the account holder’s behalf or engage in activity in the account; but depending on your circumstances, a trusted contact could add another layer of vigilance against scams.
Conner has a handle on his father's investment accounts. Because his father still likes the idea of buying and selling stocks, Conner uses an online meeting website so they can each meet online virtually and do small trades together.
In addition, Conner is doggedly working to get some of his father's money for the newsletter subscriptions refunded. So far, he has recouped $26,000.
9. Monitor accounts
There are a few handy technological tools for fighting fraud. One layer of protection to consider is FidSafe®, a free, secure online safe deposit box, to save digital backups of electronically scanned essential documents such as bank and investment account statements, birth certificates, insurance policies, passwords, tax records, wills, and more.
EverSafe sends suspicious activity alerts, including warnings for unusual withdrawals, missing deposits, odd charges, changes in spending patterns, and much more.
You might pick 3 or 4 people to get alerts. With both of these services, the people who are allowed access to the financial documents can be friends, a family lawyer, or biological family members. If privacy is a stumbling block, the service can be set up in a way where you don't have to reveal amounts you hold in accounts. Monthly fees range from $7.49 for up to 5 financial accounts to $22.99 for unlimited accounts and monthly credit reports. (Fidelity customers receive a discount.)
Conner set up a FidSafe box for his father. "Dad's bank, credit card, and investment account numbers, and the passwords, and his renter's and automobile insurance policy and long-term care policy are stored there," he says. In addition to his father and his stepmother, Conner, his sister, and his stepmother's daughter have access to the virtual vault.
10. Schedule family financial meetings
When it comes to preventing elder financial abuse, regular family conversations about your parents' fiscal world is crucial. "Build up to regularly scheduled meetings. That is ultimately the best way to stay engaged and on top of the situation. Keep a tight running agenda for these meetings, however. And, most importantly, don't allow them to be a time to hash out family dynamics. Make those conversations separate," advises Habbershon.
Immediately after the discovery of the newsletter subscriptions, Conner, his sister, his stepmother's daughter, and his father talked weekly, but then the phone calls slacked off.
More recently, though, Conner's sister discovered on a review of her father's credit report that he had opened a new credit card without telling them. The siblings quickly started biweekly conference calls. "We're encouraging our stepmother to be part of the conversation too," says Conner. "Because she is living with him now, she is truly our eyes and ears on the ground."
Next steps to consider
Start a conversation
Already working 1-on-1 with us? Schedule an appointmentLog In Required
Create your plan for retirement income.
Access articles, webinars, and ideas on wealth planning and investment strategies.