When Karson asked her father about his later-in-life plans around finances and long-term care, he gave his typical “You don’t have to worry about it” response. This time, she wasn’t willing to let it go. She was feeling a growing weight of responsibility and even resentment around these issues with the older generation in her life. She felt it with her father and his second wife, Meg. She also felt it with her mother and with her husband Jordon’s parents.
“None of them are willing to talk about anything to do with their later-in-life planning!” she shouted to Jordon. “Why do they think it is OK to keep us in the dark?”
It’s fairly common for families to end up feeling stuck and overwhelmed by complex and emotional topics like aging and planning for later in life. Just think of everything wrapped up in these topics for Karson and her family: her relationship with her father, their blended family dynamics, the senior generation’s fears around aging and loss of control, her relationship with her siblings, and the uncertainty of not knowing how to proceed.
Conversation Cues can help you create movement
It almost sounds trite, but it’s important for Karson, and Jordon, to hit pause and reflect on the “normalcy” of their current family and planning situation, and to reframe the problem. It’s not just an “I need information” problem. It’s a “How do we reframe our conversation?” problem.
One way for Karson’s family to get unstuck is to tease out the individual topics and engage family members around the life stage realities they are all experiencing. Step into how people are feeling and thinking about the future. That’s what the eight Conversation Cues are for. They set you up to discuss information and decisions in the context of your relationships and family.
1. Voice-Vote
- Principle: Impacted people should have a voice and maybe a vote.
- Mindset: Gather people’s views by separating giving voice from having a vote.
- Reflective question: “Who should have voice and who should have vote in this decision?”
Karson felt cut off from both voice and vote on her family’s planning topics and it led to her anger and frustration. She wants to talk, but she doesn’t want to overreach and act as if she has a vote. She does want to express her views about having a voice in decisions that might impact her and discuss how she can offer help and care.
It could sound like, “Dad, can we have a ‘voice’ conversation? I’m not asking to be part of your decisions. I would just love to hear your thinking and talk about where your decisions might impact Jordon and me.”
2. Wish-Fear
- Principle: Wishes and fears are the most intimate part of a person.
- Mindset: Start with the wish to understand your flipside fears.
- Reflective question: “What are your wishes or fears around this topic or decision?”
Our wishes and fears reflect the most intimate parts of us, and they lie somewhere behind every decision. It can be hard for people to talk about them, and our approach requires some mutual vulnerability. Starting a conversation with facts and information seldom gets to wishes and fears.
Fears are often the spoken or unspoken drivers behind our behavior. Karson’s father was genuinely fearful of becoming a burden to his daughter. Don’t discount a fear. Explore it and acknowledge it. Then to the flipside wish—there is always a wish behind a fear: “Dad, what is your wish for how you and Meg live during your later years?”
3. Transparency-Disclosure
- Principle: Transparency sets up ongoing dialogue beyond point-in-time disclosures.
- Mindset: Move the conversation from disclosing information to sense-making about life through transparency.
- Reflective question: “What information do people need to help them make sense of their life?”
Cultivating age-appropriate transparency through ongoing dialogue helps people make sense of the life they are experiencing. While disclosing information is important, it can also feel one-sided and may not always be timely from the receiver’s perspective.
Karson’s father defaulted to a “when I decide” approach. Her emotional reaction wasn’t just about not knowing facts, it was about not knowing how to help and care for her family, and she and Jordon didn’t know how to plan for their own life. The conversation is, “Dad, I want to know how I can help you in the future. To do that, we need to talk about what you are thinking and planning.”
5. Fair-Equal
- Principle: Fair doesn’t always mean equal.
- Mindset: Explore perceptions of fairness to avoid defaulting to fair-is-equal.
- Reflective question: “What is your perception of fairness around this situation or decision?”
Karson’s father would often say that “everything will be equal in the end” between the siblings, but she knew things already weren’t equal. Her financial circumstances, lifestyle, and career were very different from her siblings, especially her school-teacher sister who was a single mom. Also, what about Meg?
Ironically, the more there are differences within families, the more parents tend to default to fair-is-equal, yet the reality is that all things are seldom equal. Karson and her family have an opportunity to explore each other’s perceptions of fairness around future choices. She could say, “I would love to talk about what it means to help each other in the family, now and into the future.”
6. Hard-Charged
- Principle: Topics move from hard to charged when someone personalizes them.
- Mindset: Notice when the energy and reactivity around a topic have escalated it from a hard to charged conversation.
- Reflective question: “What topics are charged in your family?”
The hard conversations Karson wants to have are filled with layers of complexity, like dependent living, future care, wealth transfer, and change of control. A topic moves from hard to charged when it touches on someone’s identity—their deeply held beliefs, values, and vision of who they are.
When a topic becomes charged, it evokes emotions that escalate from reactivity to judgment, absolute statements, and even polarizing right/wrong hard lines. Planning had become charged for Karson. She felt unable to fulfill her vision of herself as a caregiver. The conversation for her and Jordon is, “What’s making this so charged for me? How do I express my wishes and emotions around planning?”
7. Alignment-Agreement
- Principle: Alignment is the first step toward finding agreement.
- Mindset: Seek alignment around a shared understanding of a topic before moving to agreement.
- Reflective question: “Where is a drive for agreement leading to conflict and debate rather than movement and dialogue?”
One way for Karson to move beyond her frustration with the older generation’s reluctance to share their later-in-life plans is to focus on how to have the conversation. She could shift away from trying to get them to agree on whether to share information, what to share, when to share it, and is it “right?” That sets up a debate that could end in a stalemate or conflict.
Instead, Karson can step above agreement and focus on alignment. This is a higher-level conversation about a shared vision for the future, guiding principles for how to partner, what it means to care for each other, and how to continue thinking and planning together. Karson could ask, “How are you envisioning us navigating your later years together?”
8. Closeness-Distance
- Principle: Every decision can create more closeness or distance.
- Mindset: Monitor the closeness or distance your decisions create in your relationships and family.
- Reflective question: “How will this conversation and decision create more closeness or distance in our relationships?”
Overcome resistors to talking
We all feel some natural resistors to talking about complex and emotional planning topics, but talking is an important part of deepening connections in our family, especially around planning. Use the Conversation Cues to help guide you into the emotional and relational parts of the conversation so you don’t just focus on facts and information.
The key is to start slow. Don’t overreach or over expect. Gently lean in with curiosity and empathy. The planning mindset is “The more we can talk about, the more potential we have for planning intimacy ‘today’ and ‘someday.’”