View full transcript
HEATHER HEGEDUS: Hi there everybody. Thanks so much for making the time to join us for another episode of Market Sense. I’m Heather Hegedus with Fidelity. Third quarter earnings season is wrapping up and results from NVIDIA and several major retailers are going to be coming out. And with NVIDIA’s leadership changing, the report could offer fresh clues about the strength of the AI boom. While retail earnings should provide a read on consumer spending as we approach the holiday season already. Plus, we are expecting another blockbuster IPO to cap off the week.
So to talk about these latest headlines and what they might mean for investors, we’re thrilled to be joined today, as we often are, by Jurrien Timmer, of course, Fidelity’s Director of Global Macro. We’re also excited to welcome back Ryan Oldham to the show today. Ryan is a Fidelity portfolio manager and research director who manages Fidelity’s Canada fund. Ryan says there’s a lot of potential growth happening just north of the border, and we asked him to come on the show to talk about where he’s seeing value in the market right now.
So thank you both for making the time. And Ryan, welcome back.
RYAN OLDHAM: Thanks for having me back.
JURRIEN TIMMER: Great to see you both. Welcome back, Ryan.
RYAN: Thank you.
HEATHER: Let’s jump right in. Lots to talk about. Today is Tuesday, November 17. Jurrien, we don’t normally talk about specific stocks here on Market Sense. But we have been getting a lot of questions from our audience in the last few days about NVIDIA. No surprise. So the AI theme has been a major market driver. But these recent developments around NVIDIA are a reminder that even the strongest stories can sometimes face unexpected challenges.
So I’m wondering from you, when a market leading company tied to a major, major investment theme, I mean, arguably like the linchpin of this AI theme, faces unexpected headlines, how should investors think about that broader theme now? And does this alter the AI opportunity in your view or is this just another case for the importance of diversification?
JURRIEN: Well, so this, obviously, the headlines have been dramatic, and they probably haven’t played out yet. And certainly the tech industry is full big names. I mean, we don’t have to look far. We look at SpaceX and other companies, and even going back in history, Steve Jobs at Apple, Jeff Bezos at Amazon, those batons were all passed in time. And I do think that this too shall pass. I assume this NVIDIA has a good bench of leadership. But it happens at a time when people were already questioning whether this whole AI boom has a circular financing component to it and whether companies were overordering or double ordering or at what point the supply would catch up to the demand. And the news from this week and last week doesn’t really change that.
Obviously, the technology is a game-chaning one that’s affecting us all near and far. And the real questions are about the financial modeling, the plumbing of how much money is needed to build this thing out, and can the market self-regulate, or does it need to be regulated by voters? And we saw that with the blue wave kind of an anti-data center vibe going on there. And I think the news generally is pretty constructive that the market actually is self-regulating. And by that I mean that if a company gets over its skis to borrow too much money that’s unsecured and that is of questionable quality, the market will reprice that debt.
And that’s what we’ve seen with what we call the Neoclouds in recent weeks, which are the high yield data center builders. Whereas the investment grade companies are still fine. And so the markets are differentiating between what’s feasible and what’s sustainable. And, of course, later this week, presumably we will get the Anthropic IPO. And that will be another test in terms of what the market will bear in terms of the demand for capital. Because the demand for capital obviously is enormous, and there’s probably only a limit to how much of that can be absorbed. And that is the market doing its own regulatory thing.
And I think ultimately that’s a good thing, because otherwise you run the risk that it goes off the tracks down the road. And so the markets right now are churning. There’s a lot of rotation going on between the I names, the semiconductors, the non AI names and the market has seemed sort of eerily calm, if you will, for the last five or six months. the S&P has not gone anywhere, but under the hood, the big cap weighted names, the big tech names have been under pressure, have been rotated out of, whereas the rest of the market has been rotated into. And that has amassed a fair amount of churn that we’re seeing.
And I think the markets are doing what they always do. And that I think ultimately is a good thing.
HEATHER: You kind of answered a little bit of my next question that I was going to ask you. But we’re nearing the end of quarter three earnings season. 84% of companies in the S&P beating earnings estimates. On the surface, it sounds pretty good. But you were just talking about the churning, the market rotation, the rotation of leadership. And when you dig beneath the headlines, what are you seeing as we still get these amazing earnings reports coming out?
JURRIEN: So there are three dimensions to this. One is, of course, earnings have been on a spectacular run. The forward earnings estimate. So what investors are expecting companies to deliver over the next 12 months. That estimate has risen 39% over the last 12 months. You need to go to major recoveries from big recessions to get those kinds of numbers. For instance, after COVID, the recovery was about 40%, but that’s after falling dramatically.
Today, the 39% is without a fall, it’s just an earnings boom. But the data are starting to look like the growth rate is peaking. And by that, I don’t mean that earnings are peaking. But the growth rate is peaking. And that makes sense because earnings can’t grow at 40% at infinitum. Like, mathematically, it just doesn’t work. So in all likelihood, earnings growth will slow to about 20%, based on what investors are expecting over the next 12 months versus the current number. And so a move from 40% to 20%, it sounds dramatic, but remember, the historical average growth rate for earnings is about 7, 8%.
So if we only go down to 20, then I think the markets will be fine with that, especially at a time when the PE ratio that investors are paying for those earnings is already quite low. I mean, the forward PE is only 18 times. And there’s a few reasons for that. One of them is, rates are rising. That tends to lower the present value of future cash flows. Also, companies are spending so much on CapEx, at least the large companies, that they are spending less money on buying back shares. And that’s sort of an inside baseball thing, but generally that lowers the PE as well.
And then finally, investors don’t tend to pay top PE multiples for top earnings growth because earnings are cyclical. So there are a number of moving parts here. But earnings growth is peaking. And really the big question is, to what degree will it slow down? And if it’s only to 20 or even 15%, I think the markets will take that in stride.
HEATHER: All right. Earnings peaking, I know you’re watching that. But as we’d like to do on this show, we also like to talk about specific investing topic. So we’ve talked a little bit about the US market headlines. We want to shift our focus today to Canada. And Ryan is one of our brilliant portfolio managers here. And I want to be clear, you manage Canadian funds. So you’re not doing this for Fidelity Canada. This is for US investors investing in Canadian funds, Canadian stocks. And you’re also Canadian.
So I think it’d be great, first of all, if you just told us a little bit about your background, I know you’re from Montreal. Does that also mean that you play hockey?
RYAN: I did grow up playing hockey. I haven’t played hockey in years. But yeah, I grew up in Montreal, in the Western part of the island, if people know Montreal. I went to Concordia for my undergrad and McGill University for my MBA, and then I was recruited out of McGill, 19 years ago, to work for the International equities team. And when I showed up, they looked at me and said, you’re Canadian you must know energy. So they made me an energy analyst, even though Montreal is as far away from Fort McMurray as you can be.
But I grew up loving stocks. My dad was tangentially in finance, but not really an investor. But he sort of taught me some things, and I learned early on that I really loved it. And being a bit of a nerd, you could actually make money being a nerd. And so I just found myself loving to invest.
HEATHER: Well our audience always enjoys hearing about the unique backgrounds of our portfolio managers. So thank you for indulging me there and talking a little bit about your background, because each one of you, I think, has something that drives you every day. Being Canadian, you know a lot about the country. And you say Canada is entering a new chapter of growth. I would love to hear from you about why you think that growth is so attractive right now, and what is happening that has you feeling so optimistic about Canada?
RYAN: Canada has a lot of what the world needs. It’s blessed with some of the world’s largest oil reserves uranium, potash, as well as copper, rare earths. Not to mention the world’s largest freshwater reserves. Unfortunately, country’s been a little complacent about some of these advantages, and in fact, did things to deemphasize development that would maximize Canada’s advantages over the last several years. But in other words, the country didn’t exploit its resources and created a lot of red tape that made projects like LNG, mine developments, oil pipelines onerous.
The pressure created by trade disagreements and the change of government in recent years, the administration has taken measures to simplify the process for project approvals across the spectrum. In other words, deregulation, which has made people feel optimistic about the prospects for Canada over the next decade. This includes pipelines, transportation, investments, ports, military commitments, to mention a few. And this could mean billions in direct investment, which would be a major driver for the economy.
HEATHER: And what stood out as strengths in Canadian investments over the past year, Ryan? Well,
RYAN: Canadian equities delivered a strong gain in the last six months, supported by several tailwinds, including increasing demand for copper and gold, rising oil prices, and supportive monetary policy. Canada’s monetary policy remains steady, with its central bank’s benchmark rate set at 2 and a quarter. Considered a neutral policy stance. The country’s banks performed very well. Banks primary revenue come from net interest income, the spread between what they pay on deposits and the yields they earn on loans.
And that spread historically tends to increase when interest rates return to more normal levels, as opposed to the elevated levels of 22 and 24. Lastly, the US-Israeli-Iran conflict spurred a significant spike in oil prices in the period’s final months, with Iran’s closing of the Strait of Hormuz, a pivotal waterway for transportation of oil, nat gas and other global commodities. Energy prices have surged across the board.
HEATHER: All right. So, Jurrien, let’s bring you back in here for a macro view for a quick second. We talk to a lot of portfolio managers from other countries. We’ve talked to emerging markets portfolio managers. How might investors, when they’re looking at the menu of international diversifiers, how might investors think about Canada?
JURRIEN: So as we’ve talked about over the past really several years. To me, the playing field between the US and the rest of the world, including Canada, has really leveled out. And the AI boom, ironically, has only compounded that because when we look in the US, the Mag Seven that have been the generals that have been leading the charge really for the last 10, 12 years. And that’s because they returned a lot of the earnings that they made back to shareholders as dividends and mostly as buybacks, while the rest of the world tend to do that much less.
It wasn’t in the culture, in the corporate culture to do that. Now, with the AI, with the CapEx build out, and the Mag Seven, for instance, they used to pay out, let’s say, $0.90 on the dollar of earnings back to shareholders. Now, that is $0.30 on the dollar. Whereas other countries and not just Canada, but Europe and Japan as well, have gone from, let’s say, 50 to now, 70. And Canada actually wins the battle in terms of that payout math, returning $0.88 on the dollar, on the Canadian dollar, back to shareholders. And that has to do with the heavyweight in the indices of financials, of course, which tend to pay higher dividends, have higher yields.
But so from my perspective, as a global asset allocator, that is a very attractive feature, again, developed markets, including Canada. And it gives them an edge these days over the Mag Seven. US financials would also benefit the way Canadians do, but a much more level playing field. And then you can look at valuations which tend to be lower outside the US. So Canada is in a sweet spot as a diversifier for an otherwise very tech heavy S&P 500.
HEATHER: It’s a sweet spot to play on financial stocks, which are affected by things like rates. And we know rates are higher right now. OK, so we can’t talk about Canadian investment opportunities without addressing the issue of tariffs. Ryan, is trade policy with the US something that you think could be a risk here that could hamper growth for Canadian businesses or have the midterm elections here in the US suddenly made it harder for the Trump administration to impose those tariffs on Canada? What are you watching right now in regards to this?
RYAN: Yeah, when you look at exports from Canada to the US, excluding energy in 25, the number was about $280 billion. About 75% to 80% of this is what we call USMCA exempt, which is the trade agreement between Canada and Mexico and the US. Tariffs overall went from 0 to about 5% overall. The headlines look scary, but the reality is modest and digestible under the current scenario. However, this is where I get cautious. If we’re to tear up USMCA, and implemented a 20% to 25% tariff across the board like has been talked about, the Canadian economy would be hurt.
The thing is, though, the Canadian economy is not the Canadian stock market, which we’ll get into later. Jurrien alluded to this, but we’ll get into to what that means. But the way an aggressive trade war would manifest would be through employment in the industrial heartland of Canada, which is the province of Ontario. Being the most exposed to traditional industry, auto, steel, things like that. This would manifest in the medium term in unemployment, and the consequence would be bank earnings, which would suffer through housing weakness and loan defaults.
Tariffs aren’t simple, though, and Canada runs a deficit with a significant number of states in the US which happen to be Republican. Add to that the cost pressures the American consumer is going through. The politics of tariffs just got a lot more difficult post us midterms, which I think will force a compromise. I’ll leave you with one last point on this. And the tariff dispute has galvanized the Canadian people in a way I haven’t seen in my lifetime. I think this will give its politicians the resolve to not take a bad deal and look both inward to reduce inter-provincial friction and outward, seeking alternative markets for trade, diluting exposure to the US over time. Like, possibly doing deals with Europe and other countries.
So it’s not all bad and it’s manageable, but it’s something we have to watch.
HEATHER: Certainly something you’re watching. You alluded to this, so let’s talk about what makes the Canadian stock market so different from the US stock market. And what does that mean for investors?
RYAN: Yeah, I think that the discussion of this market versus that market has to start with the discussion of how different the composition of the market is in Canada versus the US, and versus its own economy. So, for example, the Canadian market is 60% weighted to banks, energy and materials. In the US, this number is 17%. The flip side of this is healthcare, tech, and communications where Canada is 10% and the US is 51% So this makes for a very different set of drivers that will drive the markets.
Canada is heavily weighted to, obviously, very economically sensitive industries, making it, ironically, in some ways more driven by the health of the US economy than the actual US market is. And although Canada’s exposed to AI through derivative exposures like uranium, copper, and industrial CapEx, Canada’s very underexposed to direct AI through tech versus the US. This is why the diversification question makes sense. You get a very, very different exposure in Canada than you do in the US.
HEATHER: Very different exposure. So the Canadian stock market is, in some ways, more driven by the health of the US economy, due to it being more weighted towards industries that are economically sensitive to factors like rates, than it is driven by the health of the Canadian economy. Is that right?
RYAN: Ironically, yeah. And I mean, if you add on the fact that 10% of another 10% is the rail industry. It’s just these very economically sensitive industries.
HEATHER: OK, thanks for clearing that up. So Jurrien, I know traveled to Canada a lot to meet with Fidelity investors. Just wondering if the questions you get from investors there, are they any different from the questions you’re getting from American investors? What do they usually ask you when you are speaking to Canadian investors?
JURRIEN: I am there a lot, and I actually do a version of this show every Monday for Canadian investment advisors, so I know them very well. I love the Canadians. And the questions tend to be similar, whether I’m in Asia or in Canada or in the US. It’s about AI, of course. It’s about interest rates. But of course, in Canada it’s very much focused also on trade, as Ryan says. Especially maybe a year ago when the trade war or the trade conflicts were looming, it would be like, what did we do to deserve this? Was the question.
But generally, Canada is a smaller market, sort of relative to other major regions. So Canadians tend to have to look outward to invest because the pond is smaller for them. And so they tend to be very focused on global events and especially US policy.
HEATHER: And for our audience, if you’re interested in checking out that European show on Monday’s, quick plug, it’s called Fidelity Connects. And you can get that wherever you get your podcasts or on YouTube as well. Just like us, those are our Canadian partners up North. So, Ryan, we’ve talked a lot about AI stocks in the US. Just wondering how Canada is positioned in the AI ecosystem right now and what might be coming as well.
We saw a lot of voter pushback here in the United States during the midterm elections about voters who don’t want these data centers built in their backyards in places like Texas and Ohio. Is there any chance those data centers might travel north?
RYAN: So when people think about the AI boom, they usually think about technology companies, obviously. But Canada’s natural resources and power infrastructure could make it an important player in this market. Canada is blessed with 20% of the world’s fresh water, and has exploited that, to some extent, with 60% of its electricity coming from hydroelectricity. Add to that the abundance of natural gas, land. 90% of the Canadian population lives within 100 miles of the US Border. There’s lots of land up there to build data centers. And plus, the cold temperatures Canada is known for make it a natural market to build data centers.
So Canada is endowed with some of the largest uranium reserves in the world, and is one of the only games in town for Western society to source incremental supply. Putting this all together, Canada has a great long term opportunity to help the world build AI infrastructure. But Canada has a lot of work to do to make sure it’s ready to do that.
HEATHER: And lastly, because we’re getting tight on time here. Ryan, for investors who were intrigued by what you had to say today about Canada’s story, where are you finding or where have you seen rather opportunities that the market may have underappreciated?
RYAN: Canada has this rocks and trees reputation.
HEATHER: What do you mean by that? When we say rocks and trees.
RYAN: Oil and materials, gold, lumber. These are the traditional industries for Canada, which I understand and respect. It’s a strength for Canada. But there’s some interesting dynamics in Canada that have always interested me and something I’ve talked about over the years. It’s that Canada is slightly less competitive versus the US across industries. For example, there’s only six banks of consequence. There’s a real oligopoly with a port system that’s connected to it. One real hard discount player. Concentrated telecom industry.
Why is this? I think it’s a multitude of reasons, including government support, language barriers, geographic spread than simultaneously a very dense population in the cities. So it makes for an economy that has less competition. There’s just like less, it makes sense for less players to try to attack that market with only 40 million people.
HEATHER: They historically have done very well for you.
JURRIEN: Yeah.
HEATHER: All right. So we are almost at the 20 minute mark, but we do have time for a quick Timbers Take. A lot of headlines this week, Jurrien. Curious what you are watching right now.
JURRIEN: Well obviously NVIDIA’s earnings tonight and how that whole drama will play out. But more importantly, the Anthropic IPO, I think will tell us a lot about the ongoing supply of capital at a time when the demand for capital remains insatiable. So that’ll be something to watch.
HEATHER: All right, we got to leave it at that. Ryan, Jurrien, terrific discussion today. And for our audience, if you are interested in researching mutual funds like Ryan’s, just head to Fidelity.com/Fundscreener and there you can choose your criteria and actually get some fun picks from Fidelity, as well as independent experts that you might want to consider. On behalf of Jurrien and Ryan, I’m Heather Hegedus. We’re off next week because of the Thanksgiving holiday. Hope you take time out to spend with your loved ones, and we will be back here the following Tuesday at two o’clock Eastern, with a replay always available as well.
Have a great holiday and great rest of your week.