The big U.S. stock indexes are telling different stories

A handful of growth stocks that have surged this year have an outsize influence on the Nasdaq and the S&P 500.

  • By Karen Langley,
  • The Wall Street Journal
  • Facebook.
  • Twitter.
  • LinkedIn.
  • Print

The divergence in the performance of the major U.S. stock indexes this year is the widest in more than a decade.

A surge in big technology stocks has helped the Nasdaq Composite (.IXIC) rally 12% in 2020, while the Dow Jones Industrial Average (.DJI) of blue-chip stocks is down 8.8%. The benchmark S&P 500 (.SPX) is hovering in between them, off 3.5%.

The Nasdaq’s advantage over the Dow and S&P 500 is the biggest since 1983. The gap between the S&P 500 and the Dow is the widest since 2002, when the Dow was ahead.

One explanation for the gap in returns: A handful of growth stocks that have surged this year have an outsize influence on the Nasdaq and the S&P 500. Apple Inc., (AAPL) Microsoft Corp., (MSFT) Inc., (AMZN) Google parent Alphabet Inc. (GOOG) and Facebook Inc. (FB) together account for about 40% of the Nasdaq and 20% of the S&P. Of those stocks, only Apple and Microsoft are in the Dow.

The disparities add to the challenges facing investors who are trying to make sense of a dizzying stretch of volatility in markets. Valuing stocks became increasingly difficult after the coronavirus pandemic brought the economy to a halt and companies from Caterpillar Inc. (CAT) to McDonald’s Corp. (MCD) to PayPal Holdings Inc. (PYPL) pulled forecasts.

Although economic data have improved in recent weeks, many investors say they expect the recovery to remain uneven and they are bracing for more turbulence ahead as the presidential election season ramps up.

“You really need to triangulate across the three different indices,” said Susan Schmidt, head of U.S. equities at Aviva Investors (AVVIY). “You can’t depend on any one index right now. You really do need to consider all three of them and know what’s in them.”

The S&P 500 has long been considered the broadest gauge, accounting for about 80% of the available market capitalization of the U.S. stock market. The Dow, on the other hand, comprises just 30 stocks—many of which are economically sensitive—and is weighted by price, instead of market value. And the Nasdaq Composite is generally deemed a tech benchmark, composed of the approximately 2,700 stocks listed on the Nasdaq Stock Market.

The stay-at-home practices adopted to help slow the spread of the virus have accelerated digital trends that have benefited many big tech stocks. Shares of Apple, Microsoft, Amazon, Alphabet and Facebook have rallied this year, led by Amazon’s 47% advance.

Other industries haven’t kept up. The three sectors of the S&P 500 that contain those stocks—information technology for Microsoft and Apple; consumer discretionary for Amazon; and communication services for Alphabet and Facebook—are the only groups in positive territory for the year. The energy, financial, industrial and utility segments are down by double digits.

“All the big companies are, in some way or another, with almost no exception, heavily focused on some dimension of tech,” said Bob Browne, chief investment officer at Northern Trust. “That has actually been a good thing in terms of return, but it’s not a good thing in terms of diversification going forward.”

Although tech stocks have a similar weighting in the S&P 500 and Dow, at 27% and 26%, some of those in the Dow don’t have the same growth prospects—and that’s evident in their share prices. Neither Cisco Systems Inc. (CSCO), which had warned of a pause in customer spending even before the pandemic, nor Intel Corp. (INTC), which has faced competition from chip-making rival Advanced Micro Devices Inc. (AMD) as well as manufacturing issues, have reclaimed their dot-com era highs. Cisco shares are off 5.8% this year, while Intel is up 0.4%.

“The fact that the Dow Jones does not have Amazon especially, and then Alphabet and Facebook, definitely has contributed to the underperformance,” said James Ragan, director of wealth management research at D.A. Davidson.

It’s unlikely those stocks, particularly Amazon and Alphabet, would be candidates to join the Dow because their high share prices would skew the index. Amazon’s shares trade above $2,500, while Alphabet’s Class A shares are near $1,500.

The Dow is calculated by adding the prices of the 30 stocks and dividing by a factor that accounts for changes like stock splits. This means that companies with a higher share price hold greater sway, regardless of their total market value.

The S&P 500 and Nasdaq Composite, by contrast, are weighted by market capitalization, so larger companies hold greater influence. The equal-weighted S&P 500—which gives the same status to both the smallest and largest companies in the index—has underperformed its traditional counterpart this year, falling 11%.

Another issue for the Dow: Only six of its 30 constituents are up for the year and nearly all of their gains have been wiped out by the slide in shares of Boeing Co. (BA) The aerospace company’s shares have tumbled 42% this year due to the slump in air travel prompted by the pandemic and the grounding of its 737 MAX jet.

Boeing’s slide has knocked about 926 points off the index in 2020, nearly erasing the 1,032-point contribution from Apple, Microsoft, Home Depot Inc. (HD), Visa Inc. (V), Walmart Inc. (WMT) and Intel, according to Dow Jones Market Data. Its tumble has also tilted the balance of the index away from the eponymous industrials sector whose weighting has dropped to 14% from 19% at the start of 2020. The group makes up just 8% of the S&P 500.

The Dow’s underperformance versus the S&P 500 is hardly new. The former has surged 298% from its financial crisis low on March 9, 2009, but has still underperformed the S&P 500’s 361% advance. However, since the 2016 presidential election, the indexes are neck and neck, up 42% and 46%, respectively.

“This has been a market environment where tech has been viewed as a defensive area for investors,” said Kristina Hooper, chief global market strategist at Invesco. “Industrials have largely been left by the wayside, and so that’s reflected in the changing composition of the Dow.”

  • Facebook.
  • Twitter.
  • LinkedIn.
  • Print

For more news you can use to help guide your financial life, visit our Insights page.

Copyright © 2020 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Votes are submitted voluntarily by individuals and reflect their own opinion of the article's helpfulness. A percentage value for helpfulness will display once a sufficient number of votes have been submitted.
Please enter a valid e-mail address
Please enter a valid e-mail address
Important legal information about the e-mail you will be sending. By using this service, you agree to input your real e-mail address and only send it to people you know. It is a violation of law in some jurisdictions to falsely identify yourself in an e-mail. All information you provide will be used by Fidelity solely for the purpose of sending the e-mail on your behalf.The subject line of the e-mail you send will be " "

Your e-mail has been sent.

Your e-mail has been sent.

You May Also Like...

Top 5 investing articles of the week

Our editors compiled the five most-popular investing articles of the week. This selection of reader favories delivers investment strategies, market analysis and stock recommendations from leading news sources.

Investing amid the resurgence of coronavirus

John Normand of JPMorgan says investors are right to see the resurgence in coronavirus infections as a risk factor, but advises against turning defensive or negative on markets.

How to boost your Social Security payments

Workers who familiarize themselves with the Social Security rules will be better able to maximize their payments. Here are 10 rules about the program that all workers should know.